Refill Ink for IP8700 Series Printer

riclin

Fan of Printing
Joined
Oct 17, 2025
Messages
76
Reaction score
31
Points
55
Location
Melbourne, Australia
Printer Model
Canon Pro-10S, Canon iP8760
Has anyone evaluated Canon's GI-63 bottle inks used with the G660 Megatank printer for refilling the CLI-651 (551, 251 etc depending on region) carts in the IP8700 Series printer? I have been using the GI-63GY for some time and have found it to be just about identical to ink in the CLI-651GY (or equiv) cartridge. I am about to transition to the GI-63 Y, C & M inks as well and will be preparing updated printer profiles for the new inkset. I suspect that the Y & C inks will match without problems, but am uncertain about the M since the standard GI-63 inkset also includes a red ink suggesting that the magenta may be spectrally narrower than the CLI-651 equivalent. Any experience with these inks out there?

TIA.

EDIT: - the G660 is I believe a G620, 650 or 670 in other regions, and the GI-63 ink is GI-23, 53 or 73. Why does Canon insist on doing this?
 
Last edited:
If the automated cleaning routine is not successful then clear the cartridge contacts and perform a nozzle check. If the print quality is still not up to scratch you will probably have to replace the print cartridge or printhead.
 
........EDIT: - the G660 is I believe a G620, 650 or 670 in other regions, and the GI-63 ink is GI-23, 53 or 73. Why does Canon insist on doing this?......
The reason is that they can use different pricing in different parts of the world. If you live in a rich country you are probably able/willing to pay more for the products. The regionalizing prevents "grey" import from a region with lower prices. Here is a post with a list of the regions. Compare "Big Mac Index".

I don't know if the inks have been tested with your printer, but please report your results if you test them.
 
Last edited:
If the automated cleaning routine is not successful then clear the cartridge contacts and perform a nozzle check. If the print quality is still not up to scratch you will probably have to replace the print cartridge or printhead.
Umm - I think you might have cross-posted somehow Donald ...
 
The reason is that they can use different pricing in different parts of the world. If you live in a rich country you are probably able/willing to pay more for the products. The regionalizing prevents "grey" import from a region with lower prices. Here is a post with a list of the regions. Compare "Big Mac Index".

I don't know if the inks have been tested with your printer, but please report your results if you test them.
I will Peter - I've still half a dozen or so full sets of cartridges here but now have the GI-63 bottles on the shelf for when they expire - at which time I'll build new profiles and report back.
 
The reason is that they can use different pricing in different parts of the world. If you live in a rich country you are probably able/willing to pay more for the products. The regionalizing prevents "grey" import from a region with lower prices. Here is a post with a list of the regions. Compare "Big Mac Index".

I don't know if the inks have been tested with your printer, but please report your results if you test them.
OK - so the results are in. Flushed empty CLI-651 cartridges and after replacing the factory chips with auto-reset chips, refilled with Canon GI-63 (aka GI-23/53/73 etc) ink. Generally very positive results. Had anticipated possible deficiencies resulting from the absence of the red channel that is normally part of this inkset, and this was indeed measurable (although visibly not obvious) with a colormunki and spotread reading raw printed test patches. Across the measurements, the GI-63 inkset (minus Red) consistently produced a much "cleaner" magenta with a higher a*, a more negative b* and less yellow contamination. The CLI-651 (i.e. - OEM cartridges) inks produced prints that by comparison were darker, redder, and with less yellow. However once profiled using ArgyllCMS or Print Prism, the differences all but disappeared. The CLI-651 (or regional equiv) inks had a marginal win in the very extreme reds (strawberries etc on "that" test image) but it needed a very close examination to discern it - at least to my eyes. YMMV.

So I think I can confirm that the bottled GI-63 (or regional equal) inks are an available and cost-effective OEM alternative to the Canon CLI-651 (251, 551 etc) inks. A little more costly than 3rd party inks, but with the benefit of being OEM ink at a fraction of the price per ml compared to new OEM cartridges. Full benefits require the preparation of a printer profile due to the absence of the red ink normally used with this inkset, but this is easily achieved at minimal cost using a scanner based profiling tool (e.g. PrintPrism), or at somewhat higher hardware cost with ArgyllCMS and a colormunki or better spectrophometer.

Very curious to receive comments/observations/critiques from anyone else playing with this.

r/
 
Welcome. Bit of a pity - a lot of paper, ink and time went into this evaluation and I anticipated some interest. Perhaps a tad too detailed? - dunno! :rolleyes:
 
Very curious to receive comments/observations/critiques from anyone else playing with this.
Hi Riclin,

I as thinking of doingt he same thing here, actually. I am not too worried about gamut coverage and super-saturated colors, but I do care about dmax and greyscale linearity.

Would you mind sharing your ICC profiles with us? I would be very curious to see how both inkset compare.

TIA,
Wim
 
Hi Wim - I'm happy to share the profiles for comparative purposes but I strongly doubt that they'll be of any use for actual printing. I use TurboPrint which uses it's own colour mapping - different from (I would contend better than) that used by Canon. The profiles work fine in that environment, but I recently discovered for example that using a genuine Canon ICC profile as an Argyll preconditioning profile results in significant read failures with the Argyll chartread tool. I attribute this to the probability that the Canon and TurboPrint drivers map their colour generation in different ways and that the Canon profile was incompatible wiith the TurboPrint colour logic - & v.v. Replacing the Canon profile with a local TurboPrint generated profile for preconditioning completely resolved the issue. So while profiles generated using Argyll and TurboPrint work well for me, I doubt that they will provide optimal print results for a generic Canon setup.

If all you want to do is examine the CLI-651 and GI-63 profiles using a gamut viewing tool (gamutview for example) then I'm happy to upload them here. In fact I could zip up the full suite of Argyll files generated for each of the 2 inks - (ti1, ti2, ti3, ps, icc and the logfiles generated by my scripting wrapper) for you to look at. But it would need to be with the understanding that they are for comparison and not for actual use.

Let me know eh?

Cheers,

Richard (riclin)

EDIT: - I have queried the gurus at Zedo about my hypothesis regarding the apparent incompatibility of the Canon profiles with those prepared within the TurboPrint ecosystem and will report back here once I receive a reply. If on the other hand you happen to use TurboPrint or PrintFab, then my profiles should work perfectly.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top