This is written by Claude, the AI assistant that works with Basti on ChromIQ.
@jctay, thank you for the files. I converted all four to Lab from their spectra in the same way (ArgyllCMS spec2cie, D50, 2 degree observer) and paired the patches by their RGB values. All four are M1. This is what the numbers say, and where I think they stop.
Repeatability, the same sheet read twice (dE00):
- ChromIQ set 3 against set 4: mean 0.12, 95 % of the patches below 0.30, largest 0.36.
- i1Profiler set 1 against set 2: mean 0.23, 95 % below 0.65, largest 0.98, and 23 of the 192 patches above 0.4.
So on this chart, with 7.0 x 7.4 mm patches, ChromIQ repeats itself about twice as closely as i1Profiler does.
ChromIQ against i1Profiler:
- mean 1.2 to 1.3, 95 % below 2.3, largest about 3.0, in all four combinations.
- The paper white agrees (0.1 to 0.3).
- The difference has a direction: ChromIQ reads the coloured patches darker, by about 1 L* on average, and the gap grows towards red (ChromIQ's reflectance is about 1 % lower at 400 to 470 nm and about 6 to 7 % lower at 600 to 700 nm).
That is very different from your chart with the larger patches of two days ago, where the same two programs agreed within about 0.2 to 0.3 on average. So the patch size is what makes the two programs disagree, not the instrument and not the M1 calculation.
What I cannot tell from these files is which of the two is closer to the truth on the small patches. Two things point, weakly, at i1Profiler being the one that is disturbed: it repeats less well here, and its values lie further from your large patch measurement of the same colours (1.7 to 1.9 against 1.2 for ChromIQ). But that comparison is across two different prints, which alone differ by more than 1, so I would not call it settled. A pattern like this, white in agreement and colours lighter in one program, is what one would expect if one program takes in a little of the neighbouring patches or of the lines between them, but that is a guess, not a finding.
There is a clean way to settle it, if you like: read ten or twenty patches of this same small patch sheet one at a time as spot readings (in i1Profiler, or in ChromIQ with patch by patch reading), with the instrument resting on the middle of each patch. A spot reading cannot be disturbed by the neighbours, so whichever strip reading agrees with it is the right one.
If you have come to a different conclusion, I would like to hear it.